Melanocortin activation of nucleus of the solitary tract avoids anorectic tachyphylaxis and induces prolonged weight loss

THE BRAIN MELANOCORTIN PATHWAY is a key leptin target in the central nervous system and plays an essential role in the homeostatic regulation of body weight. Melanocortins are peptides cleaved from a common precursor, proopiomelanocortin (POMC). Rodents with POMC deficiency and humans with POMC mutations are hyperphagic and obese. The contribution of the central melanocortin system on the regulation of food intake and body weight has been attributed primarily to hypothalamic POMC neurons in the arcuate nucleus (ARC), which produce alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone ({alpha}-MSH), the principal central melanocortin. {alpha}-MSH and its analog, melanotan II (MTII), inhibit food intake and enhance energy expenditure mainly through activation of melanocortin 3 (MC3R) and 4 (MC4R) receptors in the hypothalamus. However, the central melanocortin system is not limited to the hypothalamus. POMC neurons and {alpha}-MSH are both found within the commissural region of the nucleus of the solitary tract (NTS) in the brain stem where MC4Rs are also expressed. Thus melanocortin signaling within the NTS may contribute to, or even play a major role in, the overall central melanocortin system activity. Additionally, because hypothalamic POMC neurons project to the NTS, the NTS could serve as a site integrating the neuroendocrine and metabolic impact of POMC, both generated within the NTS and the ARC.

The role of the NTS POMC network in energy homeostasis is just beginning to be appreciated. The functions of melanocortin action in the NTS have been explored by acute administration of pharmacological agents into the fourth ventricle or the dorsal vagal complex. These studies indicated that MC4R agonists and antagonists affect food consumption in the caudal brain stem as potently as that in the hypothalamus. In addition, central infusion of MTII into either the third or fourth ventricle also increases brown adipose tissue (BAT) thermogenesis. Thus the brain stem melanocortin pathway is responsive to acute pharmacological melanocortin stimulation and likely participates in the regulation of energy balance, possibly in tandem with the melanocortin system in the hypothalamus. Furthermore, the NTS and other brain stem nuclei are generally assumed to respond to short-term signals that regulate meal initiation and termination, whereas those in the ARC and other areas of the hypothalamus predominately respond to long-term adiposity signals. However, it remains unknown how chronic activation of the melanocortin system in the caudal brain stem, including the NTS, will affect the overall energy homeostasis.

The F344xBN rats represent an established aging rodent model to investigate adult-onset obesity, which is characterized by a modest progression in body weight and visceral adiposity gain with age. Although the aged, obese F344xBN rats maintain their hypothalamic POMC expression with age, the induction of POMC by exogenous leptin is impaired, indicating an age-related leptin resistance. Our earlier study demonstrated that these animals, albeit leptin resistant, lost significant amounts of body fat and weight in response to MTII treatment or viral-mediated POMC gene delivery into the ARC. Anorexia induced by either treatment underlies one mechanism for the weight and fat loss. Unfortunately, the reduction in food intake attenuates within days or weeks after the initiation of either therapy, limiting long-term effectiveness of these modalities in treating the adult-onset obesity. The rapid attenuation of the anorexic response, or tachyphylaxis, may be a result of dwindling melanocortin receptor function due to reduced receptors and/or increased agouti-related protein (AgRP) antagonism. Melanocortin activation in the hypothalamus leads to both increased AgRP expression and reduced MC3R and MC4R expressions. However, these responses, especially the former, may be specific to the hypothalamus because AgRP mRNA expression is limited to the ARC. Thus it is unclear whether anorexic tachyphylaxis will occur after chronic POMC overexpression in the NTS.

To address these issues, recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vector encoding murine POMC (rAAV-POMC) was microinjected into the NTS, and the long-term consequences of this POMC gene delivery on energy balance, glucose and fat metabolism, BAT thermogenesis, and mRNA levels of neuropeptides and melanocortin receptors in either the NTS or ARC were assessed.

[b]Results]* Food consumption and body weight. After rAAV-POMC administration into the NTS, food consumption decreased rapidly and became significantly different from control rats by day 3. Between days 3 and 7, the reduction in food intake reached a nadir, amounting to a 33% reduction compared with rats administered control vector. Starting at day 8, the anorexic response began to wane, yet food consumption remained diminished by >3 g/day throughout the duration of the experiment.

""
Food consumption (top) and body weight change (bottom) after rAAV-POMC (bullet) or rAAV-control ({circ}) delivery in aged obese rats. The vectors were injected at day 0. Values are means ± SE of 6 or 7 rats per group. P < 0.001 (difference from food intake and weight change with treatment by repeated-measures ANOVA).

Before vector delivery, average body weight of rAAV-POMC-treated rats was comparable to that of rAAV-control rats (585 ± 11 vs. 590 ± 6 g, respectively, at day 0). Immediately after vector delivery, both POMC and control rats lost ~20 g of body weight. This is what we normally observe after surgery in aged, obese rats. Whereas body weight of rAAV-control rats remained steady throughout the experimental period, there was a steady decrease in body weight during the first 30 days after rAAV-POMC gene delivery. After day 30, body weight stabilized in these rats despite the persistent reduction in food consumption. At the end of the experiment (day 42), rAAV-POMC rats had lost an average of 72 ± 6 g of body weight compared with 29 ± 5 g in control rats (P < 0.001).

Adiposity and serum leptin levels. The decrease in body weight with rAAV-POMC delivery was associated with diminished adiposity levels. Forty-two days after central POMC gene delivery, there was a >37% reduction in visceral adiposity, as reflected by the sum of the PWAT and retroperitoneal white adipose tissues in rAAV-POMC-treated vs. in control rats. In addition, epididymal adipose tissue was diminished by 31% with POMC overexpression. Given the difference in overall body weight, we also normalized the sum of the three fat depots to total body weight. By this calculation, visceral adiposity was also significantly reduced with POMC treatment relative to controls (3.52 ± 0.33% of total body weight vs. 4.89 ± 0.17%; P < 0.005). Serum leptin levels, another indicator of body fat mass, were 38% lower in the POMC group vs. controls.

""
Visceral adiposity and epididymal white adipose tissue (EWAT; top) and fasting serum leptin (bottom) 42 days after rAAV-POMC or rAAV-control delivery in aged obese rats. Visceral adiposity levels are represented by the sum of perirenal and retroperitoneal white adipose tissues (PWAT + RTWAT). Values are means ± SE of 6 or 7 rats per group. *P < 0.01 and **P < 0.005 (difference from POMC treatment compared with control by unpaired t-test).

Fasting insulin and glucose. Fasting glucose and insulin were determined on day 29 after POMC gene delivery. Whereas POMC treatment did not alter fasting glucose, fasting insulin levels were diminished by >60%. Calculation of the quantitative insulin sensitivity check index revealed that the rAAV-POMC-treated rats had increased insulin sensitivity.

Energy expenditure. Energy expenditure after rAAV-POMC was assessed as whole body oxygen consumption and UCP1 protein levels in BAT. Oxygen consumption was recorded at day 17 and day 25 after vector delivery. On both of these days, oxygen consumption, whether expressed as consumption per rat or normalized to body weight, was not different between rAAV-POMC-treated and control rats (data not shown). However, because food intake was still depressed in the rAAV-POMC-treated rats, it was possible that any POMC-induced increase in oxygen consumption was masked by the suppression in energy expenditure due to the diminished food intake. For this reason, we also assessed UCP1 protein levels in BAT at the termination of the experiment . Induction of UCP1 in BAT is an important marker for enhanced thermogenesis and thus energy expenditure in rodents. The activation of BAT by leptin or MTII is normally associated with an increase in UCP1 and a decline in BAT tissue mass due to the lipolysis associated with thermogenesis. In the present study, total BAT weight declined markedly with rAAV-POMC treatment, and UCP1 protein concentration was elevated by 30%. However, there was only a mild increase in total UCP1 protein per BAT.

Phosphorylation of ACC. Inactivation of ACC by phosphorylation is one indicator of augmented fatty acid oxidation and/or diminished fatty acid synthesis . We examined phosphorylation of ACC 42 days after POMC gene delivery in three tissues]
Triglyceride and NEFA. At the termination of the experiment, we assessed triglyceride levels in serum, liver, and muscle as well as NEFA level in serum. Triglyceride levels were significantly diminished by 26% in liver and by 35% in serum. There was also a trend toward a decrease in triglyceride level in skeletal muscle without significance. Parallel to the decrease in serum triglyceride, NEFA serum level was diminished by 34%.

MC3R and MC4R are believed to be the predominant melanocortin receptors in the NTS that mediate the effects of POMC-derived {alpha}-MSH on the homeostatic regulation of body weight. Whereas the expression level of MC4R in NTS was unchanged, that of MC3R was reduced by nearly 60% in rAAV-POMC-treated compared with control rats.

[b]Discussion]
With the use of neural site-directed rAAV-mediated POMC gene delivery, POMC overexpression and increased {alpha}-MSH production were observed in the NTS area at 42 days after vector delivery. Conversely, neither POMC expression nor {alpha}-MSH levels were elevated in the hypothalamus.

The chronic POMC overexpression in the NTS causes persistent but moderate anorexia, a pattern in sharp contrast to pharmacological {alpha}-MSH or MTII administration into the third or MTII administration into the fourth ventricle, which induces a suppression in caloric intake for only a few days in either normal or dietary obese mice and rats. The sustained anorexic response in the present study is also considerably longer than the 20 days of anorexia observed after rAAV-POMC gene delivery targeted to the ARC of the hypothalamus in the age-matched rats of the same strain.

The mechanism of the rapid tachyphylaxis to melanocortin treatment in pharmacological studies is not clear but may involve agonist-mediated receptor internalization and/or elevated AgRP levels. MC3R and MC4R activation by {alpha}-MSH in the hypothalamus is subject to competitive suppression by the natural antagonist, AgRP. Because hypothalamic AgRP expression rises after either peripheral MTII application or hypothalamic POMC gene delivery in young rats (our unpublished data), AgRP seems to be a good candidate for mediating the anorexic tachyphylaxis. Expression of AgRP mRNA is abundant in the ARC, and AgRP-containing neurons in the ARC project to other neurons in the hypothalamus and brain stem. However, immunohistochemical analysis identifies few AgRP-positive neurons in the NTS. In the present study, the expression of AgRP remains unchanged in both the NTS and ARC after POMC gene delivery into the NTS, and the basal level of AgRP in the NTS dwarfs that in the ARC. Thus the lack of AgRP antagonism in the NTS may be one factor preserving the anorectic response to POMC overexpression in the NTS. Another factor may involve MC3R and MC4R expressions. Our previous study with POMC gene delivery into the hypothalamus demonstrated diminished expression levels of MC3R and MC4R in the hypothalamus. On the contrary, only the expression level of MC3R was decreased in the present study, whereas MC4R expression level was unchanged. This absence of a downregulation of MC4R expression in the NTS may also contribute to the prolonged anorexia. The rAAV-mediated POMC overexpression in the NTS did result in the elevation of {alpha}-MSH peptide levels outside the NTS; therefore, the ectopic expression of POMC in the caudal brain might account for some of the responses observed.

POMC gene delivery into the NTS leads to a significant decrease in visceral adiposity and a sustained reduction in body weight in rats with adult-onset obesity. Body weight commenced to decline within days of rAAV-POMC gene delivery and continued for 30 days, after which body weight stabilized. The incongruent patterns of food intake and weight loss suggest factors other than just food intake contributed to the reduced body weight. The anorexic response displayed three phases]
In addition to the reduction in body weight, there was a substantial decrease in adiposity levels and triglyceride levels and an apparent increase in fat oxidation in muscle. These may be a direct result of enhanced energy expenditure or a consequence of chronic anorexia or both. The evidence for augmented fat oxidation was an increase in phosphorylation of ACC, a key enzyme in regulation of fat oxidation in muscle. Phosphorylation of ACC inactivates the enzyme, thus reducing the synthesis of malonyl CoA. A reduction in the latter releases the inhibition of carnitine palmitoyl transferase-1, the activity of which is the rate-limiting step in muscle mitochondrial fat oxidation. Despite the apparent increase in fat oxidation in muscle, phosphorylation of ACC was not elevated in liver and was diminished in PWAT. The latter is inconsistent with what is observed after chronic leptin treatment in young, lean rats, which substantially increase fat oxidation within the fat tissue. The pattern observed in the present study, an increase in fat oxidation in muscle and reduced fat metabolism in fat tissue, seems to agree with what would be expected after chronic food restriction. In such situations, the stored fat would be used as necessary fuel (oxidation in muscle) and not for facilitated thermogenesis (oxidation in BAT or white adipose tissue). Conceivably, the chronic anorexia is the primary cause of the apparent increase in fat oxidation in muscle rather than an overt increase in energy expenditure.

The NTS POMC over-expression also improved insulin sensitivity. The aged F344xBN rats with adult-onset obesity normally demonstrate insulin resistance and glucose intolerance. The fasting insulin levels were substantially diminished in the POMC-treated rats, and the Quantitative Insulin Sensitivity Check Index indicated increased insulin sensitivity. These data are consistent with our previous report of improved glucose metabolism and insulin sensitivity after POMC gene delivery into the hypothalamus and in agreement with other findings that central melanocortin receptor activation suppresses insulin release from the pancreas and enhances glucose metabolism. The enhanced insulin sensitivity is probably due to the substantial decrease in visceral adiposity and muscle triglyceride content by the chronic POMC treatment and could be the result of the prolonged anorexia and/or some food-independent function(s) specific to POMC overexpression.

In conclusion, POMC gene delivery directed into the NTS suppresses food intake, reduces body weight and visceral adiposity, increases muscle fat oxidation and BAT UCP1 protein levels, lowers tissue triglyceride content, and improves insulin sensitivity in rats with adult-onset obesity. The unabated hypophagia, unique to POMC overexpression in the NTS compared with in the hypothalamus, suggests that the mechanisms leading to anorexic tachyphylaxis in response to melanocortin activation in the hypothalamus are lacking in the NTS. Therefore, rAAV-POMC gene delivery to the NTS appears more efficacious than comparable activation in the hypothalamus and is a new and viable strategy to combat adult-onset obesity in rodents.